Manual vs Automatic Cars : Which Transmission is Best for You?

Your Complete Guide to Choosing Between a Manual and an Automatic Car

Are you stuck trying to decide between a manual or an automatic car? Don't worry - you're not alone! Choosing the right transmission type can significantly impact your daily driving experience, so it’s a big decision to make.

In this guide to Manual vs Automatic Cars : Which Transmission is Best for You? we'll take a closer look at both of these options. Buying a car is a big investment, so you’ll want to figure out which option best suits your lifestyle, budget, and driving style.

Our article will talk you through all of the important stuff; from how manual and automatic transmissions work, what they're like to drive day-to-day, and even what to expect when it comes to maintenance.

We’ll also weigh up the pros and cons of each type of car, as well as highlighting the cost implications. Read on to find out which transmission type might be the best fit for you…

Key Takeaways :

  • Manual Cars Benefit From Lower Initial Purchase Costs but Require More Skill to Drive.
  • Automatic Cars Provide Greater Convenience and Are Easier to Drive but Typically Cost More to Buy From New.
  • Older Cars With Manual Transmissions Generally Provide Better Fuel Economy.
  • Manual Transmissions Are Becoming Less Common in New Vehicles and Aren’t Available in Electric Cars.
  • Automatic Technology Continues to Advance With More Sophisticated Features Being Added Year-On-Year.
  • Which One You Choose Depends on Your Personal Preferences, Driving Style, and Budget.

What is the Difference Between a Manual and an Automatic Car?

A Manual Car :

A manual car has gears and therefore puts the driver in control of the gear changes when the vehicle accelerates and decelerates.

Cars with manual transmissions have three pedals - the clutch (placed on the far left), the brake (located in the middle), and the accelerator (on the right). The driver must physically shift gears using a gear stick and clutch pedal. Here's how it works:

  • The Clutch Pedal : When Pressed, It Disconnects Power Between the Engine and Transmission, Allowing You to Change Gears.
  • The Gear Stick : Usually Has 5 or 6 Forward Gears Plus a Reverse Gear, Arranged in an “H” Pattern.
A_Manual_Car

If you learn to drive in a manually-operated car, you will be taught how to change gears using this 3-step process :

  1. Press the Clutch Pedal Down.
  2. Move the Gear Stick to Select the Appropriate Gear.
  3. Gradually Release the Clutch While Gently Pressing the Accelerator Pedal.

As any driver knows, timing this process correctly prevents stalling the car and ensures a smooth gear change. 

An Automatic Car :

An automatic car handles all gear changes without any input from the driver. It typically has just two pedals - the brake (situated on the left) and the accelerator (on the right). 

Automatic transmission cars use a complex system of hydraulics, sensors, and computers to determine when to change gears. Unlike a gear stick, the gear selector is usually marked P-R-N-D (Park, Reverse, Neutral, Drive).

An_Automatic_Car

Driving an automatic car is a much simpler process than in a manual vehicle - here’s how it works:

  1. Move the Selector to ‘D’ for Drive.
  2. Press the Accelerator Pedal to Move Forward and Accelerate.
  3. Press the Brake to Slow Down or Stop.

The car’s transmission system automatically selects the appropriate gear based on the vehicle’s speed, engine load, and driving conditions. This means that all you need to think about as a driver is steering, starting, and stopping! 

New automatic cars often include additional features such as a sport mode for more aggressive gear changes, a manual mode for optional manual gear selection, multiple drive modes (such as Eco, Comfort, Sport, etc.), and paddle shifters behind the steering wheel to enable manual gear selection using your hands instead of feet. 

Which is Better - A Manual or an Automatic Car?

As you can imagine, the answer to whether a manual or automatic car is better depends entirely on your specific needs and preferences as a driver.

Which_Is_Better_a_Manual_Or_an_Automatic_Car

To help identify which is the best option for you, it’s worth considering both the driving environment and driver experience. For example :

  • If You Mainly Drive in Towns and Cities, Then an Automatic Car Is Typically Better.
  • If You’re Driving Is Largely in Rural Areas and the Countryside, Then a Manual Car May Be Preferred.
  • Consider How Much Heavy Traffic You Typically Drive In, as Lots of Stop/Start Driving Often Warrants an Automatic for Ultimate Convenience.
  • If You Like the Idea of Being in Control and Experiencing an Element of Performance Driving, Then a Manual Car Is Likely the Option for You.
  • For New Drivers, an Automatic Car Is Easier to Learn In.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Manual Cars :

PROS :​​CONS :
Better Control in Adverse Conditions​​More Challenging for New Drivers
​More Precise Speed ManagementTakes Practice to Master​
Enhanced Performance Capabilities​Risk of Stalling​
Lower Purchase Price​Less Practical in Heavy Traffic​
​Generally Cheaper to MaintainRequires Constant Attention​
​Often Better Fuel EconomyFewer New Models Are Available​
Potentially Higher Resale Value​​Limited Automatic Conversion Options
More Engaging Driving Experience​Not Available in Electric Cars​

Advantages and Disadvantages of Automatic Cars:

PROS :​​CONS :
Easier to DriveHigher Purchase Price
No Risk of StallingMore Expensive to Repair
Simpler Learning ProcessSlightly Delayed Responses
Multiple Driving Modes to Choose FromHigher Fuel Consumption in Older Models
Better Integration With Modern FeaturesLess Engaging for Driving Enthusiasts
Easier for Drivers With DisabilitiesFewer New Models Are Available​
More Widely Available
Suitable for All Skill Levels

Should I Buy a Manual Car?

If you’re thinking about choosing a manual car but aren’t quite sure, then see how many of the statements below sound like you:

  • You Love Being Hands-on With Your Driving - There’s Something Pretty Special About Mastering the Art of a Perfectly Timed Gear Change!
  • You’re Watching the Pennies and Want to Give Your Wallet a Bit of an Easier Time.
  • You’re Mostly Travelling on Country Roads Rather Than Sitting in City Traffic.
  • You’re the Type Who Enjoys Having Complete Control Over Your Car and Deciding When to Change Gear. 
  • You’re a Petrolhead by Heart and Love Going for a Drive - Even When Just Popping to the Shops!
  • You’re Not Regularly Stuck in Stop-Start Traffic (Trust Us, Your Left Leg Will Thank You).
  • You Appreciate the Simplicity of Mechanical Systems - Sometimes Less Tech Means Less to Go Wrong!

Should I Buy an Automatic Car?

If you’re leaning towards an automatic car instead, then these statements will help determine if it is right up your street:

  • You want your commute to be as stress-free as possible. No more clutch control in crawling traffic!
  • You're usually navigating city streets and dealing with endless traffic lights.
  • You'd rather focus on the road ahead than worry about which gear you should be in.
  • You share your car with family members who might not be confident with a manual.
  • You're new to driving and want to build your confidence without the extra stress of changing gear.
  • You regularly drive long distances and want to arrive at your destination feeling fresh rather than frazzled.
  • You've got a mobility issue that makes clutch control tricky.
  • You occasionally get anxious about hill starts or stalling - with an automatic, these worries will disappear!
Should_I_Buy_a_Manual_Or_Automatic_Car

Conclusion :

What you’ve got to remember is that there's no right or wrong choice here - it's all about what works best for you and your lifestyle. 

Manual cars offer greater control, lower costs, and a more engaging driving experience but require more skill and effort to operate them. In comparison, automatic cars provide convenience, accessibility, and a simpler driving experience but often come at a higher cost. 

The automotive industry continues to prioritise automatic transmissions, with many manufacturers phasing out manual options. This decision is largely driven by the demand for electric vehicles, as these are only available as automatics.  

Both transmission types still remain viable choices for different drivers and situations. As such, it’s really important to consider your daily driving conditions, budget constraints, and personal preferences when making your decision.

Manual_Vs_Automatic_Conclusion
  • If you’re still not sure which transmission option suits you, then visit our Wilsons Epsom showroom in Surrey to get behind the wheel of both vehicle types. A test drive may be just what you need to make the final decision!

FAQs and Answers:

Has our guide to manual versus automatic cars helped you make a decision as to which transmission is best for you? We hope so! If you have any other questions relating to the topic, then check out our frequently asked questions section below:

Q : Will Manual Cars Be Phased Out in the UK?

A : While manual cars aren't being immediately phased out, the transition to electric vehicles means manual transmissions will naturally decline.

From 2035, new petrol and diesel car sales will end in the UK, and since electric vehicles don't have traditional transmissions, this will effectively phase out new manual cars by that time.

However, existing manual cars will still be legal to drive and buy second-hand after 2035.

Q : Do Manuals Last Longer Than Automatics?

A : Not necessarily. The longevity of cars depends more on maintenance and driving habits than transmission type. This means that a well-maintained automatic can last just as long as a manual.

Q : Should My First Car Be a Manual or Automatic?

A : This very much depends on your personal circumstances, so below we’ve highlighted some considerations for each:

Choose a Manual Car If :

  • You Want to Learn Skills That Can Be Transferred to Any Vehicle.
  • You’re on a Tight Budget.
  • You Enjoy Being Fully Engaged With Driving.
  • You Have Time and Patience to Learn.

Choose an Automatic Car If :

  • You Want to Focus On Road Awareness Without Gear Changes.
  • You Mainly Drive in Populated Areas With Heavy Traffic.
  • You Find Learning to Drive Challenging.
  • You Have Anxiety About Stalling or Hill Starts.

Q : Are Automatics More Expensive to Insure?

A : Generally yes, automatic cars typically cost more to insure for three main reasons:

They're usually more expensive to repair
Replacement parts cost more
The vehicles themselves often have higher values
Bear in mind though that the difference is usually minimal, and other factors like your age, location, and driving history have a much bigger impact on car insurance prices.

Q : If I Learn in an Automatic Can I Drive a Manual?

A : No - if you pass your driving test in an automatic car, your licence will only allow you to drive an automatic vehicle.

To drive a manual car after passing your test in an automatic car, you'll need to take additional driving lessons in a manual car or pass another driving test in a manual vehicle.

However, if you pass your test in a manual car, you can drive both manual and automatic vehicles without taking any additional lessons or other tests.

Q : Is It Still Worth Learning in a Manual Car?

A : Yes, it can still be worthwhile learning to drive in a manual car for a number of reasons:

  • Manual Cars Are Generally Cheaper to Buy.
  • You’ll Have More Vehicle Choices, Especially in the Used Car Market.
  • The Skill Is Valuable for Driving Abroad in Places Where Manual Cars Are Still in Use.
  • Many Classic and Specialist Vehicles Are Manual.
  • The Skill Will Potentially Remain Useful in the Future.

Q : Which Is Better in Traffic - Manual or Automatic?

A : Cars with automatic transmissions are generally better in traffic because no constant clutch work is required. This results in smoother stop-start driving, a reduced risk of stalling and a more relaxed driving experience overall.

Q : Are Manual Cars Cheaper to Maintain?

A : Typically yes, a manual car is cheaper to maintain largely because it has a simpler mechanical design, fewer complex parts, more affordable replacement parts, and issues that are easier to diagnose.

Q : Can You Push Start an Automatic Car?

A : No - unlike manual cars, automatic vehicles cannot be push or bump-started because they require electrical power to engage the transmission and the hydraulic system needs the engine running in order to work.

Attempting to push start an automatic car can damage the transmission and result in hefty repair bills.

Q : Which Is Better for Fuel Economy?

A : While manual cars have had a history of better fuel economy, modern automatics often match or exceed manual fuel efficiency. In fact, some new automatic systems are specifically designed for optimum fuel efficiency.

Manual or Automatic, We've Got You Covered!

At Wilsons Epsom, we believe there's nothing better than getting behind the wheel to help you decide on which vehicle suits you. Our extensive range includes everything from nippy city runners to luxurious family cars, available with both manual and automatic transmissions.

Our website makes it super easy to find exactly what you're looking for without leaving the house. When browsing for your next car, you can use our handy search filters to sort by transmission type - rest assured that our real-time stock updates show you exactly what's available right now.

Love the Idea of a Manual?

You'll feel right at home with our fantastic selection of manual cars. From sporty numbers that'll put a smile on your face to economical daily drivers that are kind to your wallet, we've got something for every manual enthusiast.

If you're new to manual driving then don't worry as our friendly team will help you find the perfect car to start your manual journey.

Prefer the Ease of an Automatic?

You’ll be pleased to hear that our automatic range includes everything from smooth-shifting saloons to practical family-sized SUVs. Make driving a breeze by exploring our entire range and booking a test drive today.

Are You Worried About the Financial Bit?

Don't be! We've got flexible finance options to suit all budgets, and we're always happy to talk through the numbers in plain English. We’re also happy to take part-exchanges, which could make your next purchase all the more affordable.